22/08/2025
WHEN IS THE RIGHT TIME FOR A CLUB TO LET A PLAYER GO?
When is the right time for a club to let a player go? Does a player’s resignation indicate a stable or unstable relationship between the player (employee) and the club (employer)? These are the questions that come to mind following the ongoing impasse between South African club Mamelodi Sundowns and Brazilian star Lucas Ribeiro Costa.
Ribeiro, who only days ago scored the Goal of the Tournament at the 2025 FIFA Club World Cup, has found himself at the center of one of the most talked-about football disputes this year. For me, this is not just a case of following headlines; it’s about research, reflection, and building knowledge for steady progress in this profession.
One thing is clear, we will never have the full story from everyone involved. In football, as in life, no one wants to be seen as the villain.
What Happened?
According to several reports, including an article by Ben Collins of the BBC , Lucas Ribeiro Costa has terminated his contract with Mamelodi Sundowns F.C.. The move, his legal team argues, could make him the first footballer to benefit from Lassana Diarra's landmark legal victory against FIFA.
Belgian lawyer Jean-Louis Dupont, representing the 26-year-old, stated that Qatar SC had tabled an offer “well above the player's valuation” and that Ribeiro wished to join the Qatari top-flight club.
However, the BBC report claims Sundowns “attempted to drive up the price, again and again, in an unreasonable manner, without any regard for the player's personal interests, which made the deal impossible.”
Ribeiro went on to terminate his contract, originally set to run until 2028, on August 1. Now, the former Charleroi and Beveren forward has “no other choice” but to defend his case before a FIFA tribunal.
The Club’s Response
Mamelodi Sundowns, on the other hand, released a statement saying:
“Mamelodi Sundowns has received enquiries, particularly after the FIFA Club World Cup 2025, from several prominent football clubs expressing an interest in acquiring the services of certain Sundowns players. Mamelodi Sundowns is committed to continuing these discussions and negotiations, as part of its policy and deep commitment to advance the interests of the players and the Club, as well as fulfilling the objectives and interests of all parties.”
Adding more intrigue, the club’s supporters’ social media page claimed that Lucas Ribeiro is simply waiting for Sundowns to issue his International Transfer Certificate so he can move. If true, the next question is: will this be a free transfer due to the terminated contract, or did Sundowns miss an opportunity to negotiate?
Lessons for the Football World
In my opinion, transfers in football should always be a win-win situation for all parties involved. Sadly, this isn’t always how things play out.
For those of us in the business of football, these cases are lessons that should be studied attentively. Perhaps one day we can also reflect on the Alexander Isak– Newcastle United Football Club standoff with the same analytical eye. Until then, the Ribeiro case will continue to test how far clubs and players are willing to push the boundaries of contracts, loyalty, and the business of the beautiful game.
----
Powered by Tunta Sports + Entertainment
