07/12/2026
Are photographers done?
I could write a book on this topic, but here’s the heart of it.
A while back, I drove 5–6 hours with my family to Dells Mill because I had a very specific image in my head for years. On a family trip is isn't all about me. The conditions weren’t right for the shot I really wanted, so I built it myself in post-production.
I shot about 20 daytime frames on a tripod (no filters) so I could stack the water for a smooth, silky look. I already had a separate Milky Way image I’d captured earlier using a star tracker and stacked to reduce noise. Then I spent hours blending everything in Photoshop — dozens of layers, precise masking, color grading, the works. This wasn’t a casual edit. It was the result of 20+ years of learning, studying, trial and error, and thousands of dollars in equipment and experience.
Now compare that to the other photo: I grabbed a free image off the internet and typed a single prompt into an AI tool — “make the trees fall-colored, change the scene to night with the Milky Way in the background.”
It took me literally 20 seconds. I never left my chair.
The gap in effort versus reward is massive. So now what?
If you saw both images with no backstory, would you know which one took months of planning and skilled work versus the one I made in 20 seconds? Would it even matter to you? What actually makes a photo enjoyable or meaningful — the final image itself, or the story and struggle behind it?
Most people will never know the full process behind an image. They just see the result. So today, you basically have two paths to create something impressive: either invest 20 years becoming a skilled photographer… or have an internet connection.
I’m interested to hear everyone’s take on the matter.
My personal opinion: Lean into the tools. Use AI when it makes sense, but don’t forget what photography is really about. It isn’t just about getting likes — it’s about the journey. No one takes a photo of something they want to forget. My version carries a real memory and an adventure with my family. The AI one is valueless to me. I’ll probably forget it by tomorrow.