29/10/2026
The murder of Ella Taylor. Ella, a former resident of Silver Plume, was now living in Goldfield, near Victor, Colorado. Ella was 21 years old, known as a very good-looking brunette, who was an orphan and had been living with her sister for the past three years in Goldfield. Her sister, a widow, managed a private boarding house. Three brothers also lived in town.
Ella was attending the Labor Day Picnic at Grassy and was accompanied by George Brown, an intimate friend of the Taylor Family. As they were walking home from the Victor Depot, they encountered Harry Tilloston, who had been trying to win the heart of Ella for several years, but was not successful. Harry had told Ella that morning that if she went to the picnic with George, he would shoot her, which she did not believe at the time. It was noted in one newspaper that Harry had been keeping company with Ella for about three years, but she decided to relinquish him, which made him despondent; he started drinking heavily and became extremely jealous.
After some words, Harry drew his gun and shot at Ella and George, the first two shots missed. Harry then stepped to the side of Ella, almost placing the gun against her, and fired, causing a fatal wound.
What happened next depends on which witness. It was first believed that Harry killed himself. A ten-year-old boy, Frank O’Reily, who was standing about twenty feet away, said Harry shot Miss Taylor on her right side, and then fired two more shots at her. He then placed the gun at the back of his own head and pulled the trigger. Frank said that George stepped back when Harry came up and when he started shooting he ran and hid behind a building.
George’s testimony to the coroner’s jury said that he drew his revolver after Ella was struck and fired at Harry, hitting his head. The bullet pulled from Harry’s head was the same caliber as George’s gun. Five chambers in Harry’s gun were empty and only one in George’s. The coroner’s jury returned the verdict that Brown was justified in shooting Harry, and he was released.
Ella’s remains were returned to Silver Plume, her hometown, and she was buried next to her father and mother.
Mary Ella Taylor was born April 15th, 1876, in Silver Plume and died at the age of 21 at the hand of Harry Tillotson on September 6th, 1897.
Henry “Harry” Tillotson, who was born in Missouri in 1861, was buried in Victor Sunnyside Cemetery in Victor.
Pictured is the family plot of the Taylor Family in the Silver Plume Cemetery, including Ella’s grave.
History provided by newspaper articles from The Victor Record, The Morning Times, The Silver Standard, and the Georgetown Courier in 1897.