09/01/2026
I posted my review of “The Presidentess” on the Sherwood Forest page. I’ll be doing a little video on the book closer to the release date. I really enjoyed this book and I have a lot to say besides what I wrote.😂 anyone who knows me will not be surprised.
The new book on Julie Gardner Tyler, “The Presidentess” co-authored by Christopher J. Leahy and Sharon Williams , releases in just 4 weeks on September 29. Links in the comments will show where you can pre-order.
Shelly Liebler, our historical interpretation specialist, read an advanced copy and offers this review.
"Interest in Presidents and First Ladies is at an all time high in 2026. It’s only appropriate that Julia Gardiner Tyler has finally returned to the public eye with release of a new biography on her life.
Miss Julia Gardiner had captured the attention of the New York press, the 1840s version of paparazzi, including powerful NY Herald editor, James Gordon Bennett and artist, Alfred E. Baker, who mocked the debutant in caricature. She was still a young lady - only 20 years old. By the time she first shook the hand of President Tyler at a White House reception in 1842, Miss Gardiner had developed her own celebrity from both media exposure and interest generated by her beauty and charm during the Washington DC winter social season. She did not go unnoticed by the President.
Their courtship began a year later, after Tyler became a widower. Through a series of remarkable events, Julia would become the first “Bride of the White House,” marrying a sitting President, 30 years her senior, in a secret ceremony during the summer of 1844.
“The Presidentess” is her story - that of a determined woman who transformed the role of First Lady, made strategic use of publicity, navigated complicated personal, political and family dynamics, and handled strife and tragedy after the death of her husband. Despite these many challenges, she managed to reclaim the title of “First Lady” when it appeared that the Civil War had stripped it away.
The book, co-authored by Christopher J. Leahy and Sharon Williams Leahy is the first full length solo biography of Julia Gardiner Tyler. The Leahys identify several themes and set out to refute previous scholarship that had defined young Julia as a flirt and coquette seeking attention, rather than a victim of those exploiting her likeness for personal gain. Instead of shrinking from these experiences, Julia learned how to navigate her life more intentionally, aware of image and the role it played in powerful parlors and public opinion. Her eight months in the White House are often a side bar of presidential history, but in the pages of this book we see her step into a the role of First Lady during a highly contentious Presidency and take charge of the long vacant office. She immediately goes to work promoting positive aspects of her husband’s service, lobbying for his political policies, and creating a welcoming environment at the White House. And finally, she demonstrates further adaptability in her life as she transitions from a Northern to a Southern cultural perspective during years spent raising her family alongside the former President at Sherwood Forest in Charles City, Virginia.
The Leahys lead us through each era of Julia’s life, providing important details that define her character. I was particularly touched by the human side of Julia revealed in these pages. She struggles with the challenges of a highly visible blended family, entering the social structure of the James River Plantations community, health concerns including seven pregnancies, and the sometimes isolation of life on the plantation. We see her as both the belle of the ball and a woman in mourning, as loss often characterizes her journey. In the end her strong and adaptable nature ultimately sees her through, as she lobbies to restore her own standing in Washington D.C. during the post Civil War years.
The book is scholarly in nature with many primary sources, and the Leahys handily refute previous erroneous interpretations of the “Rose of Long Island” caricature, along with adding additional depth to her roles in the White House. The story of the Tyler courtship is beautifully handled, demonstrating the genuine affection that grew between the future first couple. It’s truly a long-distance courtship. After their “elopement,” Julia’s image is once again front and center, as she is personified as “Texas” during the battle for annexation. We see Julia rise to the occasion as she becomes the “Presidentess” - a title applied first to Dolley Madison.
There were many times in reading this work that I needed to stop and reflect on the distinctly female hardships that Julia often struggled through, still so familiar to many of us today. The story of when she first sees her portrait hanging in the White House is a full circle moment for Julia and quite moving. Truly recognition of the unspoken bond between the First Ladies.
I will say that my current professional association is with that of Sherwood Forest, the home of John and Julia Tyler. Being quite familiar with their history, I deeply appreciate this work as finally providing Julia Gardiner Tyler with her own story. In the daily operations at the historic site, people come to see the President’s house. But really, Julia created the mystique of Sherwood Forest - decorating the interiors and designing the grounds. We now have a clearer picture of her life and accomplishments with the publication of this work.
I also found it touching that the co-authors dedicated “The Presidentess” to the memory of Harrison Ruffin Tyler, the last living grandson of Julia Gardiner Tyler (and John Tyler) who passed away in 2025.
I recommend this book to those studying Presidential History in general and anyone with an interest in John Tyler. If you have read and enjoyed Chris Leahy’s “President Without a Party” this is a must read. Additionally, for those studying White House history, women's narratives or the 19th century, this book is a rich resource that will provide context to the evolution of the “office” of First Lady which began with Dolley Madison and continued with Julia Gardiner Tyler.
Julia would be pleased."
History in Two Voices
