11/19/2016
The Drug Enforcement Agency Sent YOU!
My attraction to street photography has grown with every shoot I do; So when I had the opportunity last weekend to take part in a photo walk through NYC with a few fellow photographers, I jumped at the chance. I’ve admired work by Bruce Gilden for some time so I thought sweet, NYC let’s go out and capture some characters! Let’s feature the “average joe”.
It was a fun day and we all got some great shots, but I had an experience which has brought up some questions (at least for me). So we came across this man shaving in the street; Yes, shaving, fully lathered up face, razor, towels the works. I saw my opportunity and I approached him, camera aimed at his reflection but when he noticed me all HELL broke loose! Freaking out he starts stomping and frantically waving his arms, yelling at the top of his lungs “the drug enforcement agency sent you!“ over and over. Stomping and pacing back and forth! I slowly backed away trying to explain, “No picture, ok, no picture, see, look no picture”. After about a minute (and about 15 feet of comfort zone) he says something that has been rattling around my brain for days. “I can't even wash my hands!” as he points to his shaving supplies… I know, not exactly but also not the point. Did he feel I invaded his privacy, disrupted his morning ritual? I know legally there is no expectation of privacy while out in public, but what are the moral obligations? As a photographer what obligations do I have to art and society? What obligations do I have to the subject?
The question is, where do we draw the line? When am I shedding light on those whom so many walk past without a second look? The forgotten, accidentally or purposely. I worry good intentions can turn into a Barnum & Bailey’s or Coney Island sideshow. Are the images created taken as an amusement, a safe place to have your laughs while pointing at the funny man? Where is the line drawn between a side-street show of oddities carefully crafted for your guilty gratification and images that bring impact? Images that serve as a reminder that we are all human no matter what problems we have? I’d like to think that for me, my photography is the latter; I will acknowledge the regular “joe”. I see you, I know you exist my brother and here is my very small attempt at showing you off to the world, they see you too.
Yes there are problems in society and we can’t forget them away. We’ll have to deal, meanwhile I will see the good, the bad and the ugly. But if by any chance there is a man shaving amidst a busy manhattan street, I will have the respect to let him do his thing. Even I like to “wash my hands” without being pestered.
Please leave your opinion below, tell me what you may think about street photography or any of the questions I’ve posed above.. Thanks!!