05/22/2026
Fifty Years Of Food.....Croton Colonial Restaurant Diner
During the recent extended 'stakeouts' of railroad activity in Croton, I found my way back to the the Croton Colonial Restaurant Diner fro the first time in a while. Twice. With the goal of avoiding too much fast food, this was a good choice for grilled chicken over salad. So good that I got the small during the the first visit, and the large when I returned. The chicken was marinated and moist. I do eat in a lot of different places, and I find that when it comes to grilled chicken over salad, many assume you'll just toss it in thousand island and not notice that they never touched it with seasoning; that is not the case here. Of course they also have the usual assortment of burgers, fish, steak, and french toast at any hour; that will be for the next visit.
If I asked you to describe a 'diner', this is what you'd imagine. They are open 8:00 AM-10:00 PM, and they have a 10 page menu. As people pursue ever more exotic cuisines, diners are having a hard time, so maybe go out and support a locally owned business this weekend if their continued existence is as important to you as it is to me.
Croton Colonial Restaurant Diner
221 South Riverside Avenue
Croton-On-Hudson, New York
Post visit pro tip learned: Until reading the website to write this, I did not know that they stopped offering bread and crackers with meals, as well as tomato, lettuce, coleslaw and pickles with sandwiches, but they are included and you can ask for them. This is a cost saving measure. I think this is a little to extreme, they could add 'available on request' on the menu, or have the waiter ask. I assumed it was not available, and it would make for a better experience if I had known.