09/18/2026
THE LOST BARN HIDING IN DELAWARE COUNTY’S 1869 MAP
An extraordinary farm, tucked into a corner
In the upper-left corner of Delaware County’s 1869 wall map is an illustration that could easily be overlooked—almost like a picture added to fill an otherwise empty space.
Its caption is “Masonville Farm; Res. of S. T. Oviatt.”
Although presented as a residence, the scene preserves something remarkable: Stephen T. Oviatt’s enormous barn, standing below an unusually long farmhouse amid orchards and cultivated grounds.
The barn disappeared in a devastating fire in 1872. The map preserved its appearance just a few years before its destruction.
There is another important clue within the map itself.
On the township plat, the barn’s distinctive T-shaped footprint is drawn and explicitly labeled “Barn.” The elongated outline of the house also appears nearby.
The farmstead stood approximately a mile north of Masonville, in Coffins Grove Township. Its location is the southeast quarter of Section 19, Township 89 North, Range 6 West, Fifth Principal Meridian. Oviatt’s larger farm extended beyond that quarter-section, with holdings in Sections 19 and 30.
Who made the map—and the missing neighboring counties
The map was published in Geneva, Illinois, by Thompson & Everts: Thomas Hinckley Thompson and Louis Humphrey Everts. Their names identify the publishing partnership; the individual artist responsible for Oviatt’s residence illustration has not been established.
The partnership’s identified county publications around this period include:
1867 Jackson County, Iowa
1868 Scott County, Iowa, and Rock Island County, Illinois. One combined map covering two counties
1869 Delaware and Linn counties, Iowa; Carroll County, Illinois. Three county maps
1870 Henry and Johnson counties, Iowa. Two county atlases
There is also a tantalizing account of Jones and Dubuque county maps.
Harrington later recalled working on them before the Jackson County project. Cartographic historian Jefferson M. Moak discussed those recollections, but the maps remain unlocated in that research. Their reported preparation does not establish that finished editions were published. That uncertain survival makes the Delaware County illustration especially valuable.
How the complete barn image was reconstructed
The new image brings the entire barn into view. The original illustration available for this reconstruction showed the right-hand portion of the scene and only part of the barn.
Completing it required combining three kinds of evidence:
The original illustration, which supplied visible architectural details and the relationship between the barn, farmhouse, and surrounding grounds.
The township plat, which independently showed the barn’s T-shaped plan and the house’s elongated footprint.
The newspaper’s measurements, which described the central building, three equal-sized wings, and an attached stable.
The crucial proportion is the size of each wing: 56 feet wide by 144 feet long. That reduces to an exact 7:18 width-to-length ratio. Each wing was therefore approximately 2.57 times as long as it was wide.
The central building’s reported dimensions, 36 by 66 feet, give a 6:11 ratio.
Those measurements and relationships guided the expanded image. They help explain why the barn needed long, substantial wings rather than short additions clustered around a central structure.
Perspective matters, too. Wings of equal ground length will appear different lengths when one points toward the viewer and another runs across the scene. Their reported proportions belong to the building’s plan; they cannot simply be checked by measuring apparent lengths across a perspective picture.
The result is an AI-assisted historical reconstruction guided by documented measurements and surviving visual evidence. The complete view includes interpretation where the original drawing provides no information. It should not be mistaken for a surviving nineteenth-century full view or a measured architectural rendering.
Just how large was this barn?
The most detailed description appeared in the Manchester Press on October 25, 1872, after a reporter visited the ruins with H. M. Congar.
The newspaper supplied these measurements:
Reported dimensions or feature
Main building
36 Ă— 66 feet
Main building’s posts
22 feet tall
Three wings
Each 56 Ă— 144 feet
Attached stable
Approximately 30 Ă— 56 feet
Root cellar
Beneath the entire main building
The 22-foot measurement describes the posts. It does not establish the height of the roof ridge.
The paper described massive stone walls and a flowing well in the cellar. Water reached different parts of the barn through a piping system that reportedly cost more than $1,500.
It placed the barn’s construction cost at approximately $27,000 and described it as the largest barn in Iowa—a contemporary newspaper’s assessment of its exceptional scale.
An overall span can be estimated, but the article does not give one directly. If two opposing 144-foot wings extended from the outside walls of the central building, with its 66-foot dimension between them, the span would be:
144 + 66 + 144 = 354 feet.
If the central building’s 36-foot dimension lay across that same direction, the corresponding span would be 324 feet.
Those are conditional calculations. The orientation of the central block and the exact treatment of the junctions must be established before either becomes a confirmed overall measurement.
The acreage also needs care. The Manchester account says the building enclosed “something over an entire acre of ground.” The Dubuque reprint repeats that claim.
Yet simply adding the reported rectangles gives 26,568 square feet for the main building and three wings, or approximately 28,248 square feet—0.65 acre—with the stable included, assuming the components do not overlap.
The man behind the farm: Ohio and Illinois
Stephen T. Oviatt was born on July 15, 1821, in Norton, Summit County, Ohio.
He married Hannah M. Downs at Hudson, Ohio, on January 25, 1843. They had seven children. According to his later obituary, all seven died before their father.
In 1845, Oviatt moved from Ohio to Winnebago County, Illinois, where farming became a major part of his life.
His obituary also recalls a California gold-rush journey, followed by four years in business at Rockford and a return to farming. The specific business and an employer have not been identified.
By April 1850, the Rockford Forum listed him as Burritt’s collector and a justice of the peace.
Then, in May 1860, his household became the subject of alarming newspaper reports.
After flour had been brought from a mill and used to make biscuits, several members of a household numbering about ten became violently ill. Oviatt reportedly began vomiting around ten in the morning, and others followed. The household included a servant girl; people who had not eaten the biscuits escaped the illness.
A physician suspected arsenic poisoning, but the reports did not establish how the suspected poison entered the food, whether anyone deliberately introduced it, or who might have been responsible.
The affected people recovered after treatment. The story appeared in the Galena Daily Courier on May 23, 1860, and the Republican and Gazette on June 2.
Hannah died that August. The available reports do not establish a connection between her death and the earlier poisoning episode.
In April 1861, Oviatt advertised his Illinois farm for lease, explaining that he wished to retire from farming. Later that year, on November 6, he married Mrs. Mary J. Heath of Rockford.
Stephen and Mary had a daughter, Anna Grace, later Mrs. O. S. Wellman.
His public standing continued to grow. In July 1867, an Illinois newspaper promoted him as a candidate for county treasurer and praised his character. That report documents his candidacy, not an election victory.
Arrival near Masonville—and the question of who built the barn
Oviatt eventually sold his Burritt farm and acquired the Masonville property.
A November 1872 Rockford Journal account said that this move had occurred “some five years ago,” suggesting approximately 1867. The 1869 map securely establishes his ownership by that date.
The barn’s construction date is less certain. The Manchester Press placed it in 1865, but qualified that recollection with “if we are correct.”
That leaves an important distinction: Oviatt is the documented owner associated with the barn, but the surviving evidence does not yet settle whether he commissioned it or purchased it already standing. Calling him its likely builder remains an attribution. No carpenter or building contractor has been identified.
The federal land record provides an earlier ownership reference: Mark Howard received the patent for the southeast quarter of Section 19 on December 10, 1855. That identifies the federal patentee, rather than establishing who sold the developed farm directly to Oviatt or who erected its buildings.
Around Oviatt, the countryside was changing rapidly.
Coffins Grove took its name from Clement Coffin, who settled there in 1840. The township was organized in 1855.
Masonville was laid out on July 22, 1858, for Francis Daniels and the Iowa Land Company, with James G. Verplank as surveyor. Its name honored R. B. Mason, the company’s president.
An early house associated with Oscar Wellman, dating to about 1854, served travelers as a stage hotel. A school followed in 1862, with Mary R. Williams as its first teacher.
The railroad helped transform the settlement. A depot erected in 1860 was replaced by a larger one in 1868; the older building became a carpentry shop.
By February 1875, the Manchester Press described a community with four stores or groceries, two hotels, two churches, a new schoolhouse, an elevator, a depot, blacksmithing, wagon and shoe shops, and professional services. Masonville stood on the Illinois Central, approximately 54 miles west of Dubuque.
Oviatt’s farm belonged to this developing agricultural and railroad community.
The Pioneer “Long House” Mansion Farmhouse
Behind the great barn stood the building that gave the illustration its title: the residence.
Its long form appears in the perspective view and is supported by the elongated footprint on the plat.
I have called it the Pioneer “Long House” Mansion Farmhouse as a descriptive name. That wording is not an established nineteenth-century name for the property, and exact house dimensions have not been found.
A newspaper account gives us a glimpse inside.
On Christmas Day, 1871, the local Union Sabbath School gathered at the Oviatt residence for a celebration. There was a Christmas tree, gifts for young and old, speaking, music, and singing.
The Manchester Press reported a large attendance and described the home’s “commodious and elegant rooms.”
The farmhouse was therefore more than an impressive backdrop. It was a place where neighbors assembled and children celebrated Christmas.
That year also brought family sorrow. Oviatt’s son William H. Oviatt died at Greeley, Colorado, on July 22, 1871, while there with horses and cattle shipped west. He had been involved in that business for about two years and had married only that March.
Public hospitality and private grief were both part of life on the farm.
The evening the barn burned
At approximately 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, October 22, 1872, a young man entered the high haymow to obtain hay for his team.
He carried an ordinary kerosene lantern and set it down while pitching hay.
Somehow he struck it—whether with his boot heel or the end of his fork, he could not say. The globe broke, oil spilled onto the dry hay, and the mow ignited almost immediately.
News reached Manchester with the seven o’clock train. By then, there was little hope of saving the building.
Inside were eleven horses and a Devon bull. They were rescued at considerable risk as the flames spread.
Most of the farm machinery was also saved, but the destruction of the barn was complete in less than an hour.
The next morning, the reporter and H. M. Congar found smoking ruins.
The detailed account recorded the following losses inside:
Nearly 100 tons of hay, approximately half of it tame hay.
300–400 bushels of wheat.
300 bushels of oats.
Approximately 300 bushels of barley.
A valuable seeder, a fanning mill, and a pair of bobs, or sled runners.
Outside, the flames also consumed stacks containing 50 tons of tame hay and 15 tons of wild hay.
Together, the reported indoor and outdoor losses approached 165 tons of hay.
Oviatt had been threshing and had already hauled much of his wheat to Masonville as it was processed. Two or three days of threshing remained. Those earlier deliveries spared him an even greater grain loss.
The building carried $10,000 in insurance, divided equally between the New York Home and Hartford companies. Grain, hay, and other contents had another $1,800 of coverage through Aetna.
The newspaper emphasized that the insurance would help, but would not cover the loss.
This account describes the destruction of the barn. It does not establish that the farmhouse burned with it.
What the fire tells us about hay storage
The inventory gives us a firm statement about the building’s practical use:
At the time of the fire, the barn contained nearly 100 tons of hay.
That is documented storage, although it does not tell us whether the haymows were full, how the hay was distributed, or what their maximum capacity was.
We can also illustrate the likely scale in cubic feet. A modern agricultural reference hosted by Michigan State University gives an average of approximately 500 cubic feet per ton for long hay. Applying that factor to nearly 100 tons suggests roughly 50,000 cubic feet of hay. This is a calculated estimate using a general storage factor, not an 1872 measurement of the loft. See the hay-storage reference.
The actual volume would depend on the hay’s condition and how tightly it had settled.
The additional 65 tons stacked outdoors must remain separate when describing what the barn itself held.
Farming continued—and the property took years to sell
Oviatt did not immediately leave Masonville after the fire.
He continued farming and participating in county affairs. He served as a
Harvest Home vice president in 1870 and appeared among township representatives in subsequent celebrations.
In January 1876, he became a director of the Delaware County Manufacturing Company, associated with manufacturing the Hopkins mower in Manchester. The enterprise later failed, so this was a business undertaking rather than an uncomplicated success story.
He also served as a Coffins Grove Township trustee in 1877.
At the county fair that September, his three pens of Poland hogs—two boars and eight sows—received favorable newspaper attention. The account praised their quality; it does not establish a particular prize.
Advertisements reveal the scale of the farm he was trying to sell. A 1875 description offered 560 acres of prairie and 10 acres of timber, with cultivated ground, tame-grass meadow, pasture, streams, two dependable wells, a stockyard fountain, orchards, shade trees, and buildings.
The property was being advertised by May 1875 and continued to appear on the market. In 1876, an advertisement quoted $25 an acre.
A sale was reported in July 1877—more than two years after the documented advertising began.
The eventual arrangement included property as well as money. An August 17, 1877, Buchanan County Bulletin report valued the farm at $17,000.
Oviatt accepted a mill and 60 acres in Stephenson County, Illinois, valued at $10,000, with the balance in cash—$7,000 by subtraction. The purchaser was identified as John D. Diffenbaugh.
The long marketing period and the exchange are documented. The surviving figures do not prove that Oviatt accepted less than his asking price or that financial desperation forced the arrangement.
A public auction followed on February 27, 1878, at ten in the morning, on the farm a mile north of Masonville.
Its advertised offerings included horses, dairy cows, Poland breeding stock, bees, a Massillon threshing machine, a Grinnell header, Gorham seeders, a Little Champion reaper, a McCormick mower, wagons, a buggy, harness, sled equipment, cultivators, plows, a feed cooker, hay, seed corn, beans, potatoes, and household furnishings.
That later auction inventory offers another picture of a substantial working farm. It should not be confused with the contents destroyed in 1872.
Back to Illinois, then Waterloo
After disposing of the Iowa property, Oviatt settled at Yellow Creek in Stephenson County, Illinois, the community later known as Pearl City.
Another serious misfortune followed.
On September 27, 1880, while hunting, he pulled a gun from a wagon with its muzzle toward himself. It discharged into his arm.
The first newspaper reports feared that amputation would be necessary.
His later obituary confirmed that he lost the arm.
He nevertheless continued traveling and conducting business. In March 1881, he visited Manchester; a subsequent notice recorded his return to Yellow Creek.
By September 1884, the Manchester Press reported that he had moved to Waterloo, Iowa.
That stay lasted about a year before another opportunity brought him to northeastern Iowa.
Brush Creek: a furniture business and a new home
In July 1885, Oviatt purchased a store and furniture stock at Brush Creek, later renamed Arlington.
He had considered entering business in Manchester, but family connections helped determine the move. Contemporary reporting pointed to his wife’s relatives at Brush Creek; his obituary specifically mentioned her aged parents.
Oviatt entered the business as its proprietor. The records do not identify an employer for whom he went to work there.
W. S. Jones, of Torrey & Jones, assisted with taking inventory during the purchase. He should not be mistaken for Oviatt’s employer.
By October 1887, Oviatt had acquired the Central House and remodeled it to combine a home with furniture salesrooms at the front. A newspaper report noted a hot-air heating system serving the building.
His advertisements also offered Demorest and Eldredge sewing machines.
An 1899 Arlington News profile described a substantial furniture stock for a community of Arlington’s size, along with wallpaper and a complete undertaking department.
The article identified W. H. Glenn as Oviatt’s trusted helper—his “right-hand man”—and portrayed Oviatt as jovial and well liked.
Brush Creek and Arlington were successive names for the same community; the name change does not represent another move.
The family—and what the map preserved
Mary died at Arlington on June 8, 1894.
Their daughter, Anna Grace, Mrs. O. S. Wellman, cared for Oviatt in his later years. He remained in Arlington until his death in March 1908, aged 86, after approximately twenty-three years in the furniture business there.
His life had taken him from Ohio to Illinois, through farming, business, family losses, public service, the destruction of an extraordinary barn, a prolonged property sale, a disabling accident, and a final business career in northeastern Iowa.
But the image that began this story preserves an earlier moment.
The long farmhouse still overlooks the grounds. The orchard stands around the buildings. Below it stretches the barn whose shape the mapmaker thought worth drawing and labeling.
That small corner illustration—and the newspaper measurements recorded after the fire—now allow us to recover something of its scale.
The complete reconstruction gives the lost barn room to be seen again, while the original map and contemporary accounts remain the evidence against which it must be judged.