29/11/2025
There are significant, interrelated issues with police attrition and retention in both Victoria and Queensland, and more broadly across the country.
Merlinskeepe Productions.
Here is a breakdown of the situation:
1. Victoria Police Officers Moving to Queensland
* Lures from Queensland: Queensland Police has actively recruited Victorian officers, offering sign-on bonuses (reported up to $20,000) and running advertising campaigns in Victoria to sweeten the deal.
* Reasons for Leaving Victoria:
* Burnout and Fatigue: Reports indicate a "brain drain" due to officer burnout, fatigue, and a feeling of lack of support.
* Vacancies and Workload: Victoria Police has faced a significant number of vacant positions (over 1100 reported vacant at one point), leading to stations closing or having reduced hours and increased workload on remaining staff.
* Pay Disputes: A deepening pay fight has been cited as a reason for officers being lured north.
* Budget Cuts: There are reports that the Victorian government has tasked police command with cutting a large amount from the police budget.
2. Police Attrition in Queensland
While Queensland is recruiting Victorian officers, it is also experiencing its own retention issues, which is common across policing in Australia:
* Burnout and Fatigue: A 100-day review found that Queensland police officers are "stretched," "fatigued," and "suffering burnout," with many reportedly doing the jobs of other government departments.
* Overwork: Like other states, officers are feeling overworked due to a surge in unfilled roles and a rise in sick leave.
* Youth Crime: Some reports link officers leaving to feeling unsupported and overworked while trying to fight what has been termed a "Youth Crime Crisis" without backup.
* General Attrition Factors: Across Australia, reasons for police attrition include:
* Stress, PTSD, and health-related issues.
* Inability to balance work-life challenges.
* Perceived low wages and lengthy shift work.
* Organisational management and workplace culture issues.
Summary
The overall situation appears to be that Queensland is benefiting from Victoria's retention crisis by recruiting its officers, but the Queensland Police Service is not immune to the same workforce pressures (burnout, high workload, fatigue) that are driving officers out of policing generally. This points to a nationwide challenge in attracting and retaining police officers in a competitive labour market.
The challenges in Victoria and Queensland are part of a broader, national issue with police workforce planning.
Governments and police federations across Australia are now implementing a mix of aggressive recruitment incentives and cultural reform strategies.
Here are the main strategies being pursued for both Recruitment (getting people in) and Retention (keeping people in):
1. Recruitment: Financial and Study Incentives (The "Lure")
The competition is now national, with states actively poaching from one another by making the initial cost of joining significantly lower.
* Paid Study Schemes (The Big Change): This is the most significant new strategy. New South Wales (NSW) is leading this by paying Student Police Officers a salary (up to $1,360 per week, plus super) for the duration of the in-academy portion of their training. This addresses the financial barrier of quitting a job to study.
* Sign-on and Relocation Bonuses:
* Queensland Police Service (QPS): Continues to offer significant incentives, including up to $20,000 paid towards relocation costs for experienced officers from other jurisdictions (like Victoria). They also offer to pay off select Higher Education debts and provide a fortnightly cost of living allowance for recruits.
* Abolishing Fees: Many states, including Queensland, have eliminated or covered the costs associated with the application process, such as testing, medical screening, and fitness testing.
* Flexibility for Lateral Transfers: There is a push to make it easier for experienced officers to move between state jurisdictions without losing all their rank or years of service (which QPS already offers, up to Senior Constable pay).
2. Retention: Addressing Burnout and Culture (The "Keep")
These strategies aim to fix the root causes of attrition: high stress, poor work-life balance, and toxic workplace cultures.
A. Mental Health and Wellbeing
* Timely, Tailored Support: Police forces (including Victoria Police and QPS) are prioritising the establishment of mentally healthy workplaces, providing better access to psychological support, and connecting officers to holistic support services.
* Staff Support Networks: Implementing or strengthening peer-to-peer support, welfare models, and dedicated networks for diverse staff.
B. Improving Work-Life Balance
* Flexible Working Arrangements: This is a major focus across the public sector, including police, to ensure the workforce better reflects the communities they serve and to attract/retain women and parents. This includes better policies for flexible rostering and paid parental leave.
* Housing in Regional Areas: The Police Federation of Australia (PFA) advocates for greater support to address the critical police housing shortage in regional and remote Australia to retain officers in those locations.
C. Culture and Career Progression
* Focus on Inclusion and Diversity: Victoria Police, in particular, has multiple action plans (CALD, LGBTIQ+, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander) focused not just on recruitment, but on retention and progression of diverse staff to ensure they feel safe and valued in the workplace.
* Better Pay and Benefits: The PFA is lobbying the Federal Government for Fringe Benefits Tax (FBT) concessions (similar to those given to hospital and ambulance workers) to allow police to salary sacrifice mortgages or have greater tax relief, recognising the unique, high-stress nature of their work.
* The "Blue Card" Initiative: A proposal from the PFA for a "Police Blue Card" (like the Defence White/Gold Cards) to provide greater access to long-term health care services for both serving and retired members, acknowledging the lifetime impact of trauma exposure.
In short, the recruitment war is being fought with money and convenience, while the retention battle is focused on culture, care, and quality of life to sustain a career in policing.