09/14/2022
The Caroni Bird (and Cat) Sanctuary
The world-class Caroni Bird Sanctuary is now home to 200 or more cats that actively hunt throughout this important mangrove ecosystem.
As a conservationist and animal welfare advocate, I find this to be one of the hardest issues to consider. On the one hand, I am acutely aware of how harmful cats can be to bird life. The Caroni Swamp provides habitat for 190 or more bird species, including the national bird, the Scarlet Ibis. Yet by one estimate, a feral cat kills 23 to 46 birds annually. This means the Caroni cats may kill between 5,000 and 10,000 birds a year.
On the other hand, there is evident kindness in providing sanctuary for the many cats of Caroni. The area is a popular dumping ground for unwanted kittens in a country where rates of feline spays and neuters are quite low. Local welfare activists provide daily food at certain gathering points, and some activists have gone so far as to spay and neuter some of the animals.
Meanwhile, in recent years, some local people concerned about the swamp have taken to poisoning the cats. Yet this has caused further harm to wildlife as poisoned carcasses are eaten by wildlife, resulting in secondary poisonings. Others have advocated for these cats to be caged and euthanized, but this has led to threats of violence by persons who have already gone to great lengths to care for these animals. As a result, the Swamp managers have not intervened.
These animals could be rounded up and dealt with humanely if money were no object. Some of the cats are clearly socialized for human interaction, so they might be put in homes. Other cats are clearly feral and could never be kept as household pets. A long-term “cattery” could be set up for such animals, which might live up to 18 years. But of course, money is a very real constraint.
Maybe one day the resources will be found or a hard choice will be made. For now, at least, the issue continues to play out as a clash of cats and birds and values and communities.